top of page

We Need to Stop Normalizing Domestic Violence in the Albanian Community-Part 2

Oct 29
11 min read

Where Did We Learn This? Patriarchy, the Kanun, Honor and Shame


In Part One, I talked about what happens when unhealthy behavior becomes familiar enough that we stop questioning it. We may know something doesn't feel right, but if we grew up around it, watched other people accept it, or were taught that it was simply part of marriage or family life, we can have a very difficult time recognizing the pattern for what it is. For Part Two, I want to go deeper into where some of these beliefs came from, because none of us were born knowing what a husband should be, what a wife should tolerate, what respect should look like, or who should have authority within a family. Those ideas were taught to us, directly and indirectly, by the generations before us.


Before I go any further, I want to clarify what I mean when I use the word Albanian. I am not speaking only about people from the country of Albania. Albanian people have historical communities throughout Kosovo, Montenegro, North Macedonia, southern Serbia and other parts of the Balkans, and today Albanian families live throughout the world. We do not all have the same history or the same family traditions. Geography, religion, political history, village life, economic circumstances and migration all shaped families differently. Even two Albanian families from the same region can have very different beliefs about marriage, gender and family. I think this distinction is important because the purpose of this conversation is not to create another stereotype about Albanians. It is to understand how certain beliefs became part of some of our families and why pieces of those beliefs can remain even generations later.


Whenever we begin talking about patriarchy in Albanian history, the Kanun usually enters the conversation. I want to be careful with that because the Kanun is sometimes treated as though it explains everything unhealthy that has ever existed between Albanian men and women. It doesn't. Domestic violence did not begin with the Kanun, and Albanian culture did not create abusive men. Violence against women has existed throughout history and across cultures. At the same time, we cannot have an honest conversation about traditional Albanian family structures without acknowledging that customary laws and social traditions developed in societies where men and women did not have equal authority.


The Kanun of Lekë Dukagjini is probably the customary code most Albanians recognize by name, particularly in connection with northern Albanian regions, but it was not the only body of customary law among Albanian communities. Different regions developed different customs and codes, and their influence varied considerably depending on where and when people lived. These systems addressed much more than marriage. They dealt with family organization, property, inheritance, obligations, hospitality, conflict, honor and the way communities maintained order. We have to understand the historical circumstances in which these traditions developed rather than looking at people who lived centuries ago through the expectations of the world we live in today.


Understanding the context, however, does not mean pretending that every part of that system was healthy or equal. Traditional family structures across many Albanian communities were strongly patriarchal. Men generally occupied positions of greater authority within the household and public life, while women were expected to fulfill different roles connected to marriage, children, domestic responsibilities, sacrifice and maintaining the family. How strongly those expectations were enforced depended on the region and the family, but the larger message about male authority and female responsibility could become deeply embedded.


This is actually the part that interests me most from a mental health and family-systems perspective. I am less interested in whether a modern Albanian family has ever read a word of the Kanun than I am in what happens when an old rule disappears but the belief underneath that rule remains. A family does not have to know the history of a belief in order to continue living by it.


A grandfather may have had very traditional beliefs about what it meant to be a man. He teaches those beliefs to his son through the way he runs his household, speaks to his wife, raises his daughters and disciplines his children. His son may reject some of what he experienced while unconsciously keeping other parts. When he becomes a father, his children learn from him. A few generations later, nobody is talking about customary law or historical patriarchy. They simply know that certain things are “how our family is.” This is how generational patterns can survive without anyone intentionally deciding to pass them down.


I see versions of this frequently in working with individuals, couples and families. People can change enormously on the outside while remaining connected to very old beliefs on the inside. A family can leave Albania, Kosovo, Montenegro or North Macedonia and build an entirely different life in America. Their daughters may be educated, financially independent and professionally successful. Their sons may have grown up almost entirely within American culture. The family may describe itself as modern, and in many ways it may be. Yet when conflict happens inside the family, an old expectation about who has authority can suddenly appear.


This is one reason the word respect has become so important in my work with couples and families. I hear it constantly. A husband may tell me his wife doesn't respect him. A wife may say she feels disrespected by her husband. Parents tell me their adult children no longer respect them. The word sounds straightforward until I ask people what respect actually means to them, and then the conversation becomes much more complicated.

For one person, respect means speaking appropriately, listening, considering another person's feelings and treating each other with dignity. That is healthy and should be expected in every relationship. For someone else, however, respect may include an expectation that the other person should not challenge a decision, disagree openly, establish certain boundaries or say no. In that situation, what is being called respect may actually contain an expectation of obedience. If someone grew up believing that being the husband or father automatically gave him greater authority, a wife disagreeing with him may not feel like ordinary disagreement. He may experience it as a challenge to his position within the family.


This is why language matters so much. A family may no longer describe itself as patriarchal, but an expectation of hierarchy can still exist underneath the language of tradition and respect. Controlling behavior can even be interpreted as protection when people have been taught that a man's responsibility is to manage or protect the women in his family. The words become softer and more modern while the underlying expectation may remain surprisingly similar.


I also believe we have to examine what these traditional systems taught men, because we will never break this cycle if the entire conversation becomes about what women were expected to tolerate. Patriarchal systems restrict women, but they also give boys very narrow messages about what it means to become a man. A boy may learn that a man is supposed to provide, protect his family, remain strong and never appear weak. Those qualities are not inherently unhealthy. The problem comes when strength is defined as emotional silence, vulnerability is treated as weakness, disagreement feels like disrespect, and anger becomes one of the only emotions a man feels permitted to express.

When a boy is taught how to be responsible but never taught how to understand his own emotions, he can grow into a man who knows how to provide for a family but has very few tools for handling rejection, insecurity, jealousy, fear or shame. Some men learn to cover those emotions with anger because anger feels safer than vulnerability. That history may help us understand a behavior, but it does not excuse the behavior. An adult remains responsible for what he does with his emotions. Culture, childhood and family history can explain how a pattern developed, but none of them give someone permission to intimidate, control or harm another person.


That distinction between explanation and excuse is something I come back to constantly in my work. If we only condemn people without understanding what shaped them, we may never get underneath the behavior enough to change it. But if we become so focused on understanding someone's childhood, trauma or culture that we stop holding the person accountable, then understanding becomes another way of protecting the pattern. Breaking cycles requires both insight and accountability.


Women also grew up within these same systems, which means patriarchal beliefs can be reinforced by women as well as men. This is an uncomfortable part of the conversation, but an important one. A mother can give her son freedoms she would never give her daughter. She can excuse his behavior because he is a boy while holding her daughter to a completely different standard. A mother-in-law may expect a daughter-in-law to tolerate the same things she was expected to tolerate. A grandmother may genuinely believe she is helping her granddaughter by teaching her to remain patient, avoid embarrassing her husband and keep marital problems inside the home.


Acknowledging this does not make women responsible for male violence. It helps us understand how family systems maintain themselves. People can reinforce a system that has also hurt them because that system is the only version of family they have ever known. Sometimes what one generation learned as survival becomes something the next generation experiences as a limitation.


This is where I have a great deal of compassion for the women who came before us. Many women lived in circumstances where their choices were extremely limited. They may not have had financial independence, legal protection, education, family support or a realistic place to go. Divorce could bring enormous social consequences, and leaving a marriage could affect far more than the husband and wife. A woman might have had to consider her children, parents, siblings, extended family and her place within the community. If her own mother had survived marriage by remaining quiet and enduring, that mother might genuinely believe she was protecting her daughter by telling her to do the same.

We can understand those women without continuing the pattern. I can respect what a woman did to survive while still believing her granddaughter deserves something different. I can understand why a mother told her daughter to stay without turning that advice into a cultural expectation for another generation. Compassion for the past and change in the present are not opposites. In healthy cycle breaking, we need both.


Honor and shame also have to be part of this conversation because family reputation has carried enormous importance across many Albanian communities. There is a beautiful side to this collective identity. Many of us grew up knowing that we belonged to something larger than ourselves. Family meant loyalty, responsibility, protection and connection. For communities that experienced war, displacement, poverty, political instability and immigration, those family bonds could also be an important source of survival.


The difficulty comes when protecting the reputation of the family becomes more important than protecting the individuals inside the family. If everyone is worried about what relatives or the community will think, a woman experiencing abuse may feel that speaking about what is happening will create consequences for everyone around her. She may worry about embarrassing her parents, affecting her children, becoming the subject of gossip or being blamed for the breakdown of the marriage. At that point, she is not simply deciding what to do about her relationship. She is carrying the perceived reputation of an entire family while trying to make that decision.


This is why the phrase “What will people say?” deserves much more attention than we give it. On the surface, it sounds like concern about gossip. Psychologically, it can become a very powerful form of social control. When people anticipate judgment strongly enough, nobody has to explicitly tell them what to do. They begin controlling their own choices because they already know what they believe the consequences will be.


The same thing can happen with privacy. Privacy is healthy. Every family and every marriage deserves appropriate privacy. Secrecy is different. When privacy becomes a rule that prevents someone from asking for help, acknowledging abuse or speaking honestly about what is happening, we have crossed into something else. Protecting the privacy of a marriage should never require protecting behavior that is harming someone inside it.

This is why I don't want us to make the Kanun responsible for everything. If we place all of this history inside an old customary code, it becomes very easy to tell ourselves that we have moved beyond it. The more difficult work is recognizing how older ideas can appear in modern families without anyone calling them by their historical names. An expectation of obedience may now be described as respect. Control may be explained as protection. Fear of community judgment may appear as concern about family reputation. Unequal expectations for sons and daughters may simply be called tradition.


None of this means that traditional Albanian marriages are automatically unhealthy. I think that distinction is essential. Two adults can choose traditional roles and have a loving, respectful and healthy marriage. A woman may choose to stay home with children. A man may choose to carry more financial responsibility. Couples are allowed to organize their lives in ways that work for them. The issue is not whether a relationship looks traditional or modern from the outside. The issue is whether both people have dignity, safety, a voice and genuine choice within it.


That is where I believe we have to become much more thoughtful as a community. There is a difference between choosing a role because it reflects your values and living inside a role because you are afraid of what will happen if you step outside of it. Respect is different from obedience, compromise is different from submission, privacy is different from secrecy, and cultural tradition is different from using culture to justify power over another person.

Albanian families have changed tremendously across the Balkans and throughout the diaspora. Women are educated, building careers, becoming financially independent and making choices that many women in previous generations simply did not have. Men are changing too. There are Albanian fathers who want to be more emotionally present with their children, husbands who want partnership rather than authority, and younger men questioning the messages they received about masculinity. I think it is important that we recognize those changes because breaking generational patterns is not something only women are doing.


At the same time, modernization does not automatically erase what families have carried for generations. A family can change economically, geographically and educationally much faster than it changes emotionally. That is why this conversation cannot remain a history lesson about what Albanians did hundreds of years ago. I am much more interested in recognizing history when it quietly shows up in the way we raise sons and daughters, define respect, respond to anger, view divorce, protect family reputation and decide which problems are allowed to leave the home.


This is not about rejecting Albanian culture. I don't want that, and I don't believe we need to choose between cultural pride and emotional health. There is so much in our culture worth preserving: our language, family connection, hospitality, resilience, traditions, history and the extraordinary ability of Albanian communities to maintain identity across borders and generations. Breaking cycles is not about throwing all of that away. It is about becoming conscious enough to decide what deserves to travel with us into the next generation and what has already caused enough harm.


So as you finish Part Two, I don't want the question to simply be whether your family ever followed the Kanun. That is actually the easier question. I want you to think about what your family taught you about being a man or a woman, what marriage requires, what respect means, how anger was handled, how differently sons and daughters were treated, what happened when someone challenged an elder, how divorce was viewed, and which family problems were never supposed to be discussed outside the home. Then ask yourself how many of those beliefs you consciously chose and how many you simply inherited.

That is where breaking a cycle begins. We cannot change everything that was handed to us, and we cannot rewrite the history that shaped our families. But once we recognize what we are carrying, we have the opportunity to decide whether it belongs in the family we are creating now.


In Part Three, I want to go deeper into one of the most common and misunderstood questions surrounding domestic violence: Why doesn't she just leave? I want to move away from judging the person who stays and look at what may actually be happening psychologically and practically inside that relationship, including fear, financial dependence, children, immigration, family pressure, shame, isolation, attachment, hope and the gradual way a person's sense of what is possible can change after living with control for a long time.


— Maria Shkreli, LMHC

Albanian Mental Wellness Hub

Where Culture and Mental Wellness Come Together.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page